The Big Mistake: Not Reviewing Your Medicare Coverage Annually (Especially in 2026)

The Big Mistake: Not Reviewing Your Medicare Coverage Annually (Especially in 2026)

Aug 25, 2025


Are you in the habit of sticking with your Medicare plan year after year, assuming no news is good news? If so, you’re not alone. Many people think a plan that worked last year will suit them fine for the next. But skipping that annual Medicare review can be a costly mistake—especially with big changes coming in 2026.
Let’s break down why this yearly check-in matters, what’s shifting in 2026, and how you can steer clear of the risks.


Why Skipping Your Annual Medicare Review is a Recipe for Frustration

Here’s the hard truth: Medicare isn’t “set it and forget it.” Plans, costs, benefits, and networks change every year. So do your health needs. Even if your current plan seems “just fine,” you might be leaving hundreds of dollars (or more) on the table, or missing out on coverage you genuinely need.
In fact, research shows:

  • Older adults overspend by an average of $368 each year on their Medicare plans.
  • Over 20% pay $500 or more than necessary—often just by staying put without reviewingimage_1.

Think about it: Would you keep auto-renewing your cell phone or streaming plan without checking if you could get a better deal or better service?

What You Risk If You Skip Your Annual Medicare Review

Some of the biggest pitfalls we see at VitalShield Insurance Services when folks don’t review each year:

  • Higher premiums or copays: Plans often raise prices quietly. You might not notice until you’re standing at the pharmacy counter or reviewing your bank statement.
  • Lost access to your favorite doctors or hospitals: Networks change all the time—sometimes your doctors drop out of your plan, or new ones become available.
  • Missed drug savings: Your medication needs can change, and some plans offer better deals or new coverage for certain drugs.
  • Penalties for late enrollment: Forgetting to act during your window can mean higher costs for years to come.

Skipping your review risks locking you into a plan that doesn’t match your needs, and sometimes, being stuck with no coverage changes until the next enrollment window comes around.

What’s Changing in 2026? (And Why This Year’s Review Matters Most)

2026 is shaping up to be a milestone year for Medicare. Here’s a snapshot of what’s on the horizon and why it matters for your wallet and well-being:

1. Part D Premiums Are Expected to Rise

Medicare Part D (your prescription drug plan) premiums will likely climb in 2026, thanks to new rules and market changes. Even if your current plan had a stable price this year, chances are you’ll see higher costs—or different benefits.

2. New Out-of-Pocket Spending Caps

A long-awaited upgrade! In 2026, Medicare will introduce stricter caps on how much you can spend out-of-pocket on prescription drugs. This change is great news for folks with high drug costs—but the details (how and when the cap kicks in, which plans have the best protection) will vary. You’ll want to review your options to make sure you’re maximizing these savings.

3. Changes to Prescription Drug Coverage Structure

  • Medicare Drug Price Negotiation: For the first time, Medicare can negotiate prices for certain high-cost drugs—which could mean reduced out-of-pocket costs, but will impact plan formularies.
  • Lower Deductibles & New Catastrophic Thresholds: The amount you pay before reaching “catastrophic” drug coverage (where costs drop significantly) will shift. Some could hit this limit sooner, saving more—but only if your plan structure fits your medication needs.

4. Medicare Advantage Rule Updates

There are new rules coming for Medicare Advantage (Part C) plans in 2026:

  • Stricter limits on prior authorizations: Plans will streamline how they approve treatments, so less red tape for you and your doctors.
  • Better appeals processes: If a plan denies coverage, the process to challenge it should get clearer and fairer.
  • More help for dual eligible Special Needs Plans: If you qualify for both Medicare and Medicaid, plans will offer stronger support, improved care coordination, and easier-to-understand ID cardsimage_2.

5. Medicaid Savings Program Eligibility Expanding in Some States

Many states are loosening eligibility for Medicaid Savings Programs in 2026. If you were just over the limit before, this could mean extra help paying premiums or co-pays—but only if you (or your agent) know to check!

How These Changes Could Affect YOU

Maybe your medicines are getting more expensive. Or you want to keep your trusted doctors. Or you’ve got new health needs on the horizon. Without a review, you could:

  • Pay more than necessary for medications.
  • Lose access to convenient or preferred pharmacies.
  • Find out too late that your plan dropped your doctor.
  • Miss cost-saving benefits just added for 2026.
  • Overlook new support for dual-eligibles or those on Medicaidimage_3.

Medicare is incredibly personal. The best plan for your neighbor or even your spouse might not be best for you. That’s why, as a “one-plan-fits-all” system, it just doesn’t work.

Why Experts Like VitalShield Make All the Difference

Sure—you could try to compare every plan on your own. But the options are overwhelming, and the fine print can be confusing (even for the pros sometimes!). At VitalShield Insurance Services, our team is trained to:

  • Unpack complicated plan language and show you what truly matters
  • Check if your doctors, specialists, and medications are still covered
  • Find upgrades or new benefits (like dental, vision, OTC, or fitness perks)
  • Spot cost increases or surprise limitations before they bite you
  • Help you apply for state or federal programs you may now qualify for

Combine all that with our casual, no-pressure style—it's just a straightforward, honest conversation. And yes, Tim and the VitalShield crew get booked up fast before and during the Annual Enrollment Period (AEP). Most other agencies will be slammed, too—so waiting is a recipe for last-minute headaches and missed opportunities.

Ready to get started? Reach out early! Schedule your review now and keep your options open.

The Steps to a Smart Annual Medicare Review

  1. Gather Your Current Info:
  2. List your docs, meds, and any health changes from the past year.
  3. Check for Notices:
  4. Plans mail out “Annual Notice of Change” letters in September—read it!
  5. Book Your Medicare Review Early:
  6. Most experts (especially ours!) fill up fast.
  7. Discuss Your Options Honestly:
  8. Ask questions. Talk priorities—cost? doctors? prescriptions?
  9. Keep Up with News:
  10. Follow us on Facebook and Instagram—we’ll post about Medicare changes, deadlines, local events, and tips all fall.

image_4

Real Talk: What Happens If You DO Skip Your Review?

Let’s put it plainly. If you don’t check your coverage in 2026, you might:

  • Overpay for basic health needs
  • Accidentally land in a plan that doesn’t fit your evolving health
  • Miss new benefits for prescriptions, dental, vision, and more
  • Get stuck without your doctors or pharmacies in-network
  • Miss deadlines and get penalized

Medicare is a moving target—but you don’t have to chase it alone.

VitalShield Is Here to Help (But Don’t Wait!)

Every year, we hear from folks who wished they’d acted sooner—usually after they discover a big change or get hit with an unexpected bill. A quick annual chat with Tim or another VitalShield Medicare expert can 100% save you from endless frustration (and sometimes, thousands of dollars).

Extra Tip: If you have family or friends who don’t review yearly, give them a nudge. We’re happy to help them, too.

Quick FAQ

Q: I like my plan and nothing feels different—do I really need a review?

A: Yes. Even if you’re happy now, your plan might change providers, costs, or what it covers—without you realizing it.

Q: Do I need to pay for a Medicare review?

A: No. Reviews are free with VitalShield—and we’ll never upsell you on something you don’t need.

Q: How do I keep up with all the changes?

A: Easy. Follow us on social or check out our updates at https://vitalshieldus.com/medicare.

Ready for 2026? Secure Your Spot Now!

We recommend every client book their Medicare review early—late September or early October is perfect. Remember: AEP is October 15 to December 7, and appointments fill up everywhere.


Stay golden (like our brand) by being proactive—let’s make 2026 your best Medicare year yet!